3 MINUTE MONDAYHi friend, “No one deserves to be praised for kindness if he does not have the strength to be bad." — La Rouchefoucauld I’ve been thinking about the difference between choosing to do a virtuous act, and being compelled by your nature. I have a tendency to see other people’s emotional states as my responsibility. If you’re not ok, then I’m not ok. That someone else’s distress is a problem for me to solve. A while ago I rang a friend to check in on them after an amicable debate. I mentioned I wanted to make sure they were alright, they said of course. I then started talking about wanting to dial back my people pleasing nature and this overbearing need to ensure everyone else is ok ahead of myself. My friend stopped me and said “be careful getting rid of that, the fact you rang to check on me is exactly one of the reasons I love you as a friend. Don’t pathologise the kindest parts of your nature.” But in many ways I didn’t CHOOSE to check in on them, I had to. Is it virtuous to do a good thing if you didn’t have any other choice other than to do the good thing? Well, the impact was good and positive so, kind of? But there’s something about it being compelled and less effortful or conscious that seems to derogate the virtuosity. So is it more virtuous to do a good thing if it took more effort? If it was harder to do something kind than to do something mean? Which creates an interesting situation - if your nature compels you to do something good, is it more virtuous to purposefully deprogram that compulsion, making you objectively a worse friend for a while, to then reintroduce the same act but consciously? That seems an unnecessarily effortful way to finally feel good about doing something kind for other people. I have no answer here, interesting question though. MODERN WISDOMI do a podcast where I pretend to have a British accent. You should subscribe on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. This week’s upcoming episodes: Monday. Thursday. Saturday. THINGS I'VE LEARNED1. “Suicide rates among men under 30 have risen by 40 percent since 2010 and are four times higher than among young women. Male suicide accounts for as many deaths as breast cancer. Men are less likely than women to go to college or buy a home. They are more likely to be lonely and are more vulnerable to addiction. Young white men from lower-income homes are worse off than their fathers on almost every economic and social indicator. There is a bigger gender gap on campuses today than in 1972 — when the government passed Title IX to prevent sex-based discrimination in education — but today the disparities in college enrolment and performance are the other way around. There is no strong evidence that young men are turning against gender equality. But they have turned away from the left because the left has turned away from them. The problems of young men are not the confections of reactionaries. This is a story of elite neglect, not voter chauvinism. The Democrats have failed to address these issues. Under the Biden administration, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has refused to acknowledge the gender disparity in suicide rates. The White House gender policy council has not tackled a single issue facing primarily boys and men. There have been initiatives to promote women in STEM and construction but nothing about encouraging men into teaching or mental health. There are women’s health research initiatives but no Office on Men’s Health. The Democrats and progressive institutions have a massive blind spot when it comes to male issues, and this was exposed in the election. At worst, men are seen not as having problems but as being the problem.” — Richard Reeves 2. A recent study found that half of babies fall asleep within 5 minutes using this method. This “transport response” may have evolved to keep babies quiet if their caregiver spots a predator and needs to carry their baby away without being noticed. — Rob Henderson 3. “You can pretend you don’t have a choice, that you don’t have the time, brains, or resources to raise your game. But then you’ve simply talked yourself into perpetual mediocrity.” — Tucker Max LIFE HACKBuy protein on the road. If you’re in a hotel for more than 7 days, just buy a good quality protein powder and a shaker. You’re going to be piecing together random sandwiches and meat sticks trying to hit your protein goals, if you’re in the same location for a bit, just save yourself the pain and go straight to the source. Big love, Try my productivity drink Neutonic. PS |
Podcaster with 1bn+ plays. I write about the most important lessons from the best thinkers on the planet. 300,000+ people read my free newsletter. Press subscribe to join.
3 MINUTE MONDAY Hi friend, The brand new Modern Wisdom Reading List Vol. 2 is live, featuring 100 more books to read before you die. Download it now - https://chriswillx.com/morebooks/ I saw a comment on one of my videos this week that really struck me. I wish I could remember who posted it but I can’t. Thank you for inspiring this essay <3 “Why is it that when I mess up it’s my fault but when other people mess up it’s also my fault?” Let’s call this The Atlas Complex. If you care too much...
3 MINUTE MONDAY Hi friend, We live with a quiet superstition: that beneath the noise of our habits, mistakes and contradictions lies a truer version of ourselves - a self that is fundamentally good. An alcoholic who gets sober is “becoming who he really is”, a sober man who starts drinking again has “lost his way.” In Scrooge, Dickens didn’t just write about a man who swapped stinginess for generosity; he wrote about a man who discovered his real nature. When Richard Nixon fell in disgrace,...
3 MINUTE MONDAY Hi friend, Humans have an asymmetry of errors. We over-index exceptions - we use things that break the pattern we’ve come to expect as a serious learning opportunity. But we tend to only learn much faster from errors of commission (things we do), not errors of omission (things we don’t do). You only learn the sting of misplaced trust when someone betrays you, but when you refuse to trust and miss out on love, partnership, or help, the loss leaves no scar to remind you. It’s...